10/16/2026
Three Bayfield city homes totaling $1.04 million sold in the third quarter.
The standout, 233 N 4th St, a cute little home just across the street from the school, sold on September 28 for $375,000, $46,000 over its $329,000 asking price. This home sold for cash after just four days on the market.
17 S 8th St, a modest home with a little red cottage out back, a home nestled between Rittenhouse and Manypenny, sold for $325,000, 100% of asking price. It was conventionally financed.
The slowest sale of the quarter, 33 S 4th St, closed July 8 for $340,000, about $25,000 under its $365,000 list price. It was on the market for 93 days. Great location. Bit of an odd layout but a reasonable selling price for a home in the city.
In the township, a place in need of an overhaul to qualify for occupancy, but one on twenty beautiful acres with a pole barn, 31715 Star Route Rd., sold for $375,000.
The average sale price for these homes was $347,000, which for Bayfield is fairly modest. Still outside the bounds of affordability for many locals, but modest relatively. Now, for a little immodesty.
A stunning lakeside home on Blue Wing Bay Rd sold quickly, despite its 1.16 million dollar price tag, in 8 days. It’s got more cool features than I could efficiently list, but I will give a shout out the turret and its spiraling wood staircase.
On Hwy 13, a modest manufactured home and a seasonal cabin closed. In Brickyard Creek, which remains hot, two homes sold. 37750 Creek Tr, which is not a condominium, sold for $950,000. The other on Bjorn Rd, for $435,000.
Median sale price across the region was $357,500 for the quarter. The average, pulled up by the two sales near or above one million, was $455,740.
Median DOM was 13 days, but 8 of the 10 homes sold in 19 days or fewer.
Talk soon!