Pettingell Professionals

Directions Website Contact the business

Pettingell Professionals Luxury Waterfront Specialist
Top 10 Producer Nationwide Coldwell Banker Realty
#1 Agent Sarasota His love for this area inspires him every day.

Roger Pettingell is a highly credentialed Coldwell Banker Realty agent and broker who specializes in luxury waterfront properties in Sarasota and Manatee Counties. Backed by a five-person professional staff, as well as decades of experience, vast community connections, and unmatched marketing expertise, buyers and sellers can expect comprehensive, personalized attention from the list to sale.

Few can match the breadth and depth of Roger’s industry knowledge and record of success. He has contracted and sold $3 billion in luxury properties in Sarasota and Manatee Counties, ranking him a consistent top producer for Coldwell Banker Realty. In the last 13 years, Roger has been named REAL Trend's #1 Real Estate Agent for Longboat Key, Bird Key, and Sarasota, as well as the #1 Coldwell Banker Realty Agent in both Sarasota County and the state of Florida.

For each and every listing, Roger and his team of marketing and management experts provide one-on-one, boutique-style service supported by the extensive resources and global reach of the Coldwell Banker® brand. Utilizing cutting-edge marketing and research tools ensures that Roger is current on the latest property, financial, and legal data. As a longtime resident, he has developed strong relationships with brokers and other industry professionals, giving him unique insight into area trends and available properties. By handling every stage of the transaction with the utmost care and efficiency, while maintaining open and prompt communication as the process moves forward, Roger and his team take the stress out of the buying and selling process.

Having owned property at L’Ambiance, Sanctuary, Grand Bay, Beachplace, Country Club Shores, Harbor Acres, and Bird Key, Roger knows the waterfront lifestyle inside and out. Roger has been actively involved in many local charities and organizations, including the Child Protection Center, Forty Carrots, John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art, Southeastern Guide Dogs, and the West Coast Black Theatre Troupe. Roger is also a member of Adopt A Family, Big Brothers Big Sisters, and the American Red Cross.
​​​​​​​

Roger currently lives in Bird Key with his wife, Alisa, and two teenage sons, Jake and Max. When not working, he can be found enjoying the beautiful Florida sunshine with his family, likely at one of his sons’ tennis tournaments. If you are ready to move into Southwest Florida’s exciting luxury market, you will not find a better representation than Roger Pettingell!

11/04/2026

Florida Just Voted for Lower Property Taxes. Now What?

Well, Florida certainly gave us something to talk about last night.

Of all the election results, one in particular caught our attention: Amendment 3, the proposal to significantly reduce property taxes in Florida, received the support it needed to pass.

We have to admit, we weren't entirely convinced it would happen. Getting 60% of voters to agree on just about anything these days is no small accomplishment. But apparently, the idea of lower property taxes is something Floridians can agree on.

And while there's plenty to discuss about the amendment itself, what interests us most is what it could mean for Sarasota's real estate market.

Beginning in 2027, qualifying homeowners will see their homestead exemption for non-school property taxes increase to $150,000, rising to $250,000 in 2028. And for owners of second homes, investment properties, and commercial real estate, the annual cap on increases in assessed value for non-school taxes will drop from 10% to 5%.

Those are meaningful changes, particularly in a market like ours, where so many homeowners maintain residences elsewhere.

But there's another interesting piece to this. The amendment establishes different eligibility rules for existing Florida residents and those who establish residency after December 31, 2026. Could that encourage some prospective buyers to reconsider their timing? And could the prospect of lower property taxes give Florida real estate another advantage as we head into the new year?

It's certainly possible, although only time will tell how much of an impact we'll actually see.

What do you think about Amendment 3? We'd love to hear your thoughts. And whether you're considering a move or simply curious about what these changes could mean for your property, we're always happy to have that conversation.

Warmly,

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals
#1 Duo in the Nation | #1 in Sarasota for 15+ Years
$400M Sales Volume in 2024 & 2025 | $3B Career Sales Volume
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury
📞 941.387.1840 | ✉️ [email protected]
🌐 www.pettingell.com

11/02/2026

Every so often, a home comes along that reminds us why we love what we do.

Not simply because of its architecture, its setting, or even its extraordinary views. But because of the way all those things come together to create something that feels entirely its own.

Piano House, on Westway Drive in Lido Shores, is one of those homes.

There are beautiful properties throughout Sarasota, but very few occupy a setting quite like this. Westway Drive has long been one of our favorite streets, tucked within one of the city's most remarkable waterfront neighborhoods, where architectural individuality, privacy, and the Gulf of Mexico come together in a way that's increasingly difficult to find.

And Piano House makes the most of every bit of it.

Its contemporary architecture is striking, certainly, but what we appreciate most is that the design is as thoughtful as it is beautiful. This is a home meant to be lived in, with generous spaces for gathering, quiet places to retreat, and six bedrooms, including two in a separate private casita that gives family and guests a wonderful sense of independence.

Beyond its gated, walled grounds, the Gulf provides an ever-changing backdrop. And with a private beach directly in front of the property, along with access to the Lido Shores beach club, the connection to the water is something truly special.

We could spend quite some time talking about the architecture, the craftsmanship, and all the little details that distinguish this home. In fact, we probably will.

But for now, we thought we'd do something a little different.

Before we introduce Piano House to the open market, we wanted you to be among the first to see it.

Because sometimes, the most interesting homes aren't the ones that need the most explaining. They're the ones that make you curious enough to want to discover more.

And that's exactly what we hope this first glimpse will do.

Some homes are simply better experienced than described. And we'd be delighted to share the rest of the story with you, including the opportunity to experience Piano House before its official market debut.

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals

10/26/2026

Sarasota Looks a Little Different From Up Here

We recently spent some time at a rather remarkable penthouse at Orchid Beach Club, and it's one of those homes that stays with you long after you've left.

Perhaps it's the views. We knew they would be spectacular, but from this extraordinary vantage point above Lido Key, you can look out across the Gulf, over Sarasota Bay, toward the downtown skyline, and all the way to Siesta Key. It's a beautiful reminder of just how special this little corner of Florida really is.

What surprised us most, though, was how much it feels like a private home. We were taken with how comfortable and welcoming it is despite its grand proportions. With nearly 6,000 square feet of living space, four generous bedrooms, and two suites that could easily serve as the primary, there's a wonderful sense of freedom here. The kitchen is the sort of place where people naturally gather, the living spaces are gracious without feeling formal, and there's even a private four-car garage, something we rarely encounter in beachfront living. That's practically a luxury of its own.

We kept finding ourselves drawn back to the terraces. There are more than 1,500 square feet of them, each offering a slightly different perspective of the coast, with views that seem to change every time you look. Imagine having breakfast overlooking the water, spending a lazy afternoon with a good book, or inviting a few friends over as the sun begins to set. We suspect you'd find a favorite spot and never want to leave. It's easy to imagine settling into a lovely routine here.

Discover 👉 orchidbeachpenthouse1102.com

Orchid Beach Club has a charm of its own, too. It's intimate, private, and thoughtfully serviced, with the beach at your doorstep and St. Armands Circle just a short distance away. All the pleasures of Sarasota are close by, yet life here feels wonderfully removed from the bustle.

We could tell you so much more about 2050 Benjamin Franklin Drive, Penthouse 1102, but we'd much rather show you. We have a feeling you'll appreciate it even more in person.

Warmest regards,
Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals

10/23/2026

From the Gulf to the Bay on Casey Key

Some properties are best understood from the numbers. This one is best understood by walking it.

Start at the Gulf, where more than 100 feet of frontage opens directly to the beach and unobstructed views across the water.

Then keep going.

Past the tropical landscape. Across more than 400 feet of depth. All the way to the bay, where another 100-plus feet of waterfront, a private dock and a boat lift create direct access to the Intracoastal.

That extraordinary span is what makes 2417 Casey Key Road so compelling.

Nearly one acre extends from one body of water to the other, offering something increasingly difficult to find on Casey Key: the opportunity to create a custom residence with the Gulf as its primary setting and boating access waiting just beyond the other side of the property.

Morning could begin at the dock. Afternoon could unfold on the beach. And sunset belongs to the Gulf.

The homesite offers exceptional freedom for a future residence, with room to imagine expansive indoor-outdoor spaces, terraces, a resort-style pool and gathering areas positioned to take full advantage of the property’s remarkable orientation.

The Gulf frontage is complemented by a newer seawall, while the bay side features a dock and boat lift added in 2022.

Private, substantial and surrounded by water, this is an increasingly rare opportunity to create a true Casey Key estate from the ground up.

This may be the nicest Gulf-to-Bay lot we have seen on Casey Key, and it is easy to understand why.

2417 Casey Key Road presents the kind of opportunity that is becoming harder and harder to find: meaningful Gulf frontage, meaningful bay frontage, exceptional depth and the freedom to create something entirely your own.

This is not simply a place to build. It is a chance to secure a remarkable stretch of Casey Key and shape a property that could be enjoyed for generations.

Let’s connect!

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals

10/20/2026

Some Views Never Get Old

Every now and then, we walk into a home and find ourselves thinking that whoever ends up living there is going to be very, very happy. And that's exactly how we feel about 3010 Grand Bay Boulevard 416.

We've always had a soft spot for Building 4 at Grand Bay. It was the last one built, and its location overlooking the marina is really something special. But what makes this particular residence so wonderful is how much of that beautiful setting you get to enjoy. From Sarasota Bay and the boats in the marina to the skyline in the distance, there's something lovely to look at in practically every direction.

And then there's the terrace! Because this Antigua residence is on the first floor, it has an unusually generous wraparound outdoor space that almost feels like another living room. We can already imagine spending a leisurely morning out there with coffee, having friends over for dinner, or simply watching the boats come and go.

Inside, there's nearly 3,000 square feet of living space, and everything feels fresh, bright, and welcoming. The home has been beautifully updated and just furnished with brand-new pieces throughout, so there's really nothing to do but move in and make yourself comfortable. And with the season just around the corner, the timing couldn't be better!

One of the things we've always loved about Grand Bay is that you get so much more than a beautiful home. Between the pools, tennis, the new clubhouse, and access to the private Bay Isles Beach Club, there's a whole lifestyle waiting just outside your door.

We really think this is one of those places that makes everyday life feel a little more like a vacation. And isn't that part of why we love living here?

Discover 👉 grandbay416.com

If you'd like to come see it, we'd be delighted to show you around. Something tells us you'll understand exactly what we mean once you experience the home for yourself.

Wishing you a wonderful day and a little sunshine from Longboat Key!

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals

10/16/2026

The Art of Sarasota

When people think of Sarasota, beautiful beaches, sunshine, and waterfront living usually come to mind. And while we love all those things, we've always felt that what makes a place truly special goes far beyond its scenery.

It's the little restaurants we return to, the familiar faces at our favorite shops, the music, the art, and the traditions that become part of our lives. After all, isn't that what makes somewhere feel like home?

Here in Sarasota, the arts have been part of our story since the days of John and Mable Ringling. Their legacy helped shape what we now proudly call Florida's Cultural Coast, a community where creativity is as much a part of everyday life as our beautiful Gulf waters.

Following the success of our Downtown Sarasota series, we're excited to introduce The Art of Sarasota, celebrating the people, places, and performances that make our city such an exceptional place to call home.

And we couldn't think of a better place to begin than the Westcoast Black Theatre Troupe, an institution that has helped shape Sarasota's cultural landscape for more than two decades.

I've been fortunate to call its founder and artistic director, Nate Jacobs, a friend for more than 25 years, going back to a time when the troupe performed in small theaters around town. What began as Nate's dream of creating opportunities for talented performers has grown into a beloved Sarasota institution, nurturing generations of young artists and even helping some make their way to Broadway.

It's people like Nate, and the passion they bring to our community, that remind us why we love Sarasota a little more every day.

Discover 👉 www.westcoastblacktheatre.org

Because a wonderful place to live isn't just about the homes, the beaches, or the beautiful views. It's about the people who give a community its heart and the things that make us feel we belong.

And Sarasota has so much of both.

With warmest regards,

Roger Pettingell & Pettingell Professionals

10/12/2026

A Summer to Remember. A Season to Believe In. ✨

There's something wonderful about being surrounded by people who believe in what they do. People who believe in a vision, a purpose, and that what we do matters, and how we do it matters just as much.

We have always believed in real estate. In the lives it touches, the dreams it fulfills, and the privilege of being part of those stories.

This summer gave us quite a few reasons to celebrate.

While Sarasota was supposedly enjoying its quieter season, our team helped buyers and sellers make important moves. Nearly $90 million in closed summer sales, bringing us to almost $190 million in sales so far this year.

Those numbers are remarkable. But what makes them meaningful is everything behind them: early mornings, late evenings, unexpected challenges, countless details, and a commitment to getting things right. Behind that work is something even more important: a shared belief in what we are building together.

We believe in Sarasota. In the enduring value of exceptional real estate. In trust, professionalism without compromise, collaboration, and always putting people first. Those pillars guide us and give us confidence in the future.

None of this would be possible without you.

To our clients, thank you for your trust. To our friends, colleagues, and partners, thank you for your support. And to our extraordinary team, thank you for bringing your talent, energy, and heart to everything we do. Every accomplishment we celebrate belongs, in some way, to all of you.

Now, we're entering one of our favorite times of year. October, November, and December bring a special energy to Sarasota. Familiar faces return, new ones discover our coast, and opportunities take shape.

We couldn't be more excited to meet more wonderful people, share more stories, and make a meaningful difference.

If this summer reminded us of anything, it's that the calendar doesn't determine what's possible. People do.

Here's to the season ahead, to believing in what we do, and to the people who make it possible.

With heartfelt gratitude,

Roger Pettingell & Pettingell Professionals

10/07/2026

Why choose when you can have both?

When people talk about true Gulf-to-Bay living, this is what they mean.

It is the rare combination buyers so often have to choose between: beach or boating, Gulf or bay, sunset walks or afternoons on the water.

Here, you do not have to choose.

At 2116 Casey Key Road, the Gulf is just a few steps from the front door, with a beautiful stretch of walkable beach extending in both directions. Behind you, the property opens to Blackburn Bay, where deep water, a private dock and easy access to the Gulf create an entirely different way to enjoy the coast: the kind of boating lifestyle Sarasota was made for.

And somehow, having both changes the feeling of the place.

You can start the morning barefoot on the beach, come home for an afternoon by the pool, and decide later that the evening is better spent on the boat. Maybe you see a few dolphins along the way. Maybe you stay out a little longer than planned.

That is the part of real estate we have always believed in.

The right home is not simply about bedrooms, square footage or even the view. It is about what life begins to look like once you are there.

And on this quiet stretch of Casey Key, life feels wonderfully connected to the water.

The house itself was designed around that setting, with wide views, generous spaces for family and friends, and outdoor areas that make it very easy to imagine spending far more time outside than in.

But the real luxury may simply be choice.

Beach or boat. Gulf or bay. Morning walk or sunset cruise.

Or, very happily, all of the above.

Discover 👉 2116caseykeyroad.com

If Casey Key has been on your mind, we would love to show you why this particular stretch feels so special.

Warmly,

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals
#1 Duo in the Nation | #1 in Sarasota for 15+ Years
$400M Sales Volume in 2024 & 2025 | $3B Career Sales Volume
Coldwell Banker Global Luxury
📞 941.387.1840 | ✉️ [email protected]
🌐 www.pettingell.com

09/30/2026

Season isn't waiting this year

It’s almost October, and somehow Sarasota already feels different.

Usually September gives us a little breathing room. A chance to reset after summer before season really begins. But this year, after nearly $85 million in summer sales, things simply haven’t slowed down.

We’re seeing people come back earlier, and buyers who might normally have waited until later in the year are already making decisions. Part of that, we think, is because they’re realizing something we’ve been seeing for a while: there may be inventory, but truly good inventory is another story.

The homes that have the right combination of location, condition, view and lifestyle are still relatively hard to find, and when something special does come along, buyers seem increasingly willing to act.

That’s one of the reasons we’re particularly excited about our new listing at The Castillian on Longboat Key.

There’s something very appealing about The Castillian. With only 60 residences between two buildings, it has a quieter, more private feeling than some of the larger beachfront communities. You get to know your neighbors, there’s less traffic, and even on a beautiful morning, the beach can somehow still feel almost like your own.

This particular residence is directly Gulf-front, beautifully updated and turnkey furnished, with those wide-open water views that are really the reason so many people fall in love with Longboat Key in the first place. More than 700 feet of beach sit just outside, and from inside, the Gulf is part of the view from nearly everywhere.

Maybe that’s what feels different about this season already. Buyers aren’t simply looking for something to buy. They’re looking for something that feels worth moving for.

And when the right one comes along, they seem to know it.

As the months ahead begin to take shape, we suspect the best opportunities may not wait around for the calendar to catch up.

If you’ve been thinking about Longboat Key, or you’re simply curious about what we’re seeing in the market right now, we’d love to hear from you.

Warmly,

Roger Pettingell, Thomas Arbuckle & Pettingell Professionals

Address

443 John Ringling Boulevard , Suite F, St. Armands Circle
Sarasota, FL
34236

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pettingell Professionals posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Pettingell Professionals:

Shortcuts

Sponsored

Share

Category

Nearby realtors & realty services