Beth Warthman, Realtor with Key Realty

Call Directions Website Contact the business

Beth Warthman, Realtor with Key Realty Top-producing Realtor® serving Fairfield County and surrounding Counties. Specializing in homes, land, and farmland.

Local roots, strong negotiation, honest guidance. Helping buyers and sellers move forward with confidence.

Does your fantasy bathroom include a fireplace?
11/10/2026

Does your fantasy bathroom include a fireplace?

🚧 Selling your home is a journey, and reaching a contract doesn't mean it's time to relax – you're only halfway to the c...
11/06/2026

🚧 Selling your home is a journey, and reaching a contract doesn't mean it's time to relax – you're only halfway to the closing table. Learn how to avoid common pitfalls in my Handbook for Home Sellers. ⏬ Download now!

function recaptchaCB() { jQuery(' ').removeAttr('disabled'); }Your Name (required)Your Email (required)Phone Number (optional)

Cooler temps are around the corner - make sure to check and replace weather stripping on all doors and windows as a part...
11/03/2026

Cooler temps are around the corner - make sure to check and replace weather stripping on all doors and windows as a part of your seasonal prep. View a complete Fall Checklist for Homeowners here.

Fall brings cooler days, football, pumpkin spice and the perfect time to prep your home for winter. Here’s what needs to get done.

🍂 Picture your home here—rolling hills, beautiful sunsets and a harvest moon over the treetops!📍 13579 Jake Tom Rd, Loga...
11/02/2026

🍂 Picture your home here—rolling hills, beautiful sunsets and a harvest moon over the treetops!

📍 13579 Jake Tom Rd, Logan | 7.588 acres

Multiple potential build sites and a small pond with room for improvement and expansion. Hocking Valley Motorcycle Club borders the property, with parks, trails and outdoor adventures nearby!

Message me for details! 740-974-8064🌳

đź’° Ask about the available 1-year interest rate buydown to help lower your payments during your first year! (see flyer in...
11/02/2026

đź’° Ask about the available 1-year interest rate buydown to help lower your payments during your first year! (see flyer in photos)

🏡 Country views with Pine Hill Golf Course right next door! ⛳

Location...Location...Location!

📍 4422 Kauffman Rd, Carroll | $385,000

This ranch sits on 1.16 acres in Bloom-Carroll Schools with an updated kitchen, finished walkout lower level, large back deck, and attached PLUS detached garages!

Message me for details or to schedule a showing!

*Buydown subject to lender approval and program terms.* Chuck Holden and The Holden Team at Rapid Mortgage Company, NMLS # 1494178

SOLD! 🌳 Congratulations to my sellers on the sale of 13312 Jake Tom Rd! Thank you for trusting me to help you get it sol...
11/02/2026

SOLD! 🌳 Congratulations to my sellers on the sale of 13312 Jake Tom Rd! Thank you for trusting me to help you get it sold. 🏡

Past inspections and on to the Closing Table!
11/01/2026

Past inspections and on to the Closing Table!

Don't forget to 'Fall Back' one hour before bed tonight!
10/31/2026

Don't forget to 'Fall Back' one hour before bed tonight!

Wishing you a safe and fun Halloween!
10/31/2026

Wishing you a safe and fun Halloween!

đźš« Struggling with Bad Credit? đź’Ş Take Control with these DIY Credit Repair tips in my FREE Home Buyer's Handbook.
10/30/2026

đźš« Struggling with Bad Credit? đź’Ş Take Control with these DIY Credit Repair tips in my FREE Home Buyer's Handbook.

function recaptchaCB() { jQuery(' ').removeAttr('disabled'); }Your Name (required)Your Email (required)Phone Number (optional)

Address

539 E. Main Street
Lancaster, OH
43130

Opening Hours

Monday 9am - 9pm
Tuesday 8am - 9pm
Wednesday 8am - 9pm
Thursday 8am - 9pm
Friday 8am - 9pm
Saturday 8am - 10pm
Sunday 9am - 10pm

Telephone

+17409748064

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Beth Warthman, Realtor with Key Realty posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Beth Warthman, Realtor with Key Realty:

Shortcuts

Share

Category