08/24/2026
Real Estate Q&A
A question I often get as a Real Estate Broker/Auctioneer:
Question:
“I want to sell my property. I was thinking I would list it first, and if it doesn’t sell, then I would have an auction. What do you think?”
Answer:
In many situations, I would recommend considering an auction first. Here’s why.
This isn’t a criticism of traditional real estate listings. A traditional listing can be the right strategy for many properties and sellers. But after many years in the real estate and auction business, I’ve seen situations where an auction can create advantages that a traditional listing may not.
One of the biggest challenges with a traditional listing is the asking price. The seller establishes a price—often with the guidance of their agent—and that number becomes the starting point for negotiations.
From the buyer’s perspective, the list price can also become a perceived ceiling. Instead of asking, “What is this property worth to me?” the buyer is often thinking, “How much can I negotiate off the asking price?”
That can shift the conversation toward negotiating down from a predetermined number rather than allowing the market to determine what the property is worth.
There are other considerations as well: marketing exposure, the uncertainty of when a property will sell, negotiations, contingencies, concessions, and the difficulty of knowing whether the property is reaching all of the potential buyers who might have an interest.
An auction takes a different approach.
An auction gives qualified buyers an opportunity to compete for the property, with the price moving upward through competitive bidding rather than downward from an asking price.
A well-planned auction can:
✔️ Create competitive bidding
✔️ Maximize exposure through focused, proactive marketing
✔️ Give interested buyers an opportunity to participate
✔️ Establish a clear sale date and timeline
✔️ Reduce prolonged negotiations
✔️ Allow the seller to establish the terms of the sale in advance
✔️ Provide greater transparency in the sales process
✔️ Give the seller a defined closing timeline so they can plan their next move
Most importantly, an auction is designed to let the market determine the price rather than trying to predict that price in advance.
Does an auction make sense for every property? Absolutely not. The right strategy depends on the property, the seller’s goals, market conditions, and the type of buyers likely to be interested.
But if you're considering selling real estate, I believe it is worth asking the question before automatically deciding to list first and auction later.
Sometimes the best strategy isn't to start by asking, “What should I list it for?”
Sometimes it's better to ask:
“What is the best way to create the greatest opportunity for my property in today's market?”
These are just a few of the reasons I often recommend considering an auction first.
After years in both real estate and auctions, I've learned that the strategy matters.