10/28/2026
If you weren’t aware, there is real uncertainty and some massive shifting going on in the short term rental world right now on the hosting side. You may have been seeing the new Airbnb rules coming out in the news or on social media.
Airbnb (similarly to Meta with regards to social media) owns well over half of the market share in our world, and has been throwing their weight around more and more as they’ve grown into the clear leader in this space.
As a small, college town STR business, we aren’t necessarily impacted to the extent that larger operators or vacation market businesses have been, but we certainly do still have a lot at stake with these many industry changes.
While I don’t agree 100% with everything she says,
this is a great response from another operator that I thought I’d share:
Dear Brian and Gus,
(We're on a first-name basis since you're my business partners, after all!)
There are good Airbnb hosts and bad Airbnb hosts. I know this firsthand because, in addition to owning and managing multiple short-term rentals, I've stayed in plenty of properties operated by bad hosts.
I understand Airbnb has a PR problem with hosts demanding that guests spend their last vacation day completing ridiculous cleaning checklists. I agree that's unacceptable. But I don't understand why Airbnb's response is to make it harder for responsible hosts to operate their businesses.
One would think that you would WANT great hosts—and w**d out the bad ones.
Your new policies do the EXACT OPPOSITE.
Let's remember what makes Airbnb's business possible. We provide the real estate, capital, furnishings, labor, maintenance, and insurance. We shoulder the financial risk and liability. Airbnb receives a portion of the revenue. Yet you're increasingly restricting our ability to protect the very assets that make your business possible.
Good hosts create amazing experiences for guests by exceeding expectations. In order to do that, there needs to be a baseline of understanding and responsibility—ON BOTH SIDES.
My greatest concern isn't the checkout chores policy. It's the new restrictions on rental agreements, identification, and guest contact information. These three things set good hosts and their guests up for success.
Let's start with the collection of IDs.
Yes, Airbnb verifies guests' IDs when they sign up. As you know, ID verification isn't transferable between people. So when a five-star adult guest books my house for his college-age kid and his friends, people who are completely unvetted by Airbnb and potentially unaware of the house rules enter my home.
Would you allow this at YOUR home?
Think about how absurd this is. I cannot check into a hotel or rent a car without being asked to show identification and giving my contact information, and I may even be asked for ID when ordering a glass of w**e. Maybe it's because those entities OWN those assets (the hotels, the cars, the businesses). Yet Airbnb wants property owners to hand over the keys to homes worth hundreds of thousands—or millions—of dollars without necessarily knowing who is actually staying there, being able to contact them easily, or being able to require a signed acknowledgment of basic house rules.
Maybe it's because Airbnb doesn't own the assets, and you think we're suckers who will take on this liability without question?
Which brings us to rental agreements.
Our rental agreements simply reinforce the rules already disclosed in our listings, including critical safety provisions such as hot tub usage. And we need guests' actual contact information for entirely practical reasons. We manage properties remotely, often thousands of miles away. If there's an emergency, we need to reach guests immediately or allow a handyman to contact them directly. That's responsible property management, not an unreasonable intrusion.
As for checkout chores, there's a difference between asking guests to clean a property and expecting basic respect for someone else's home. Nobody should have to scrub bathrooms on vacation. But leaving seven days' worth of greasy dishes in a sink, attracting insects and potentially creating plumbing problems, isn't reasonable either. And who wants the experience of a bear breaking in your guests discarded trash when you couldn't require them to take it to the bear proof dumpster in your mountain condo community?
Our homes are drastically different than a small hotel room without a kitchen and daily provided cleaning. And you know that.
Most guests are respectful. But Airbnb's highly publicized messaging risks giving people permission to behave differently. That's the critical word: permission.
And the consequences will fall on hosts, cleaners, and the next arriving guests. Many hosts are already questioning whether they can continue offering early check-ins, late checkouts, or same-day reservations because we no longer know what condition our properties will be in—or how much additional time those turnovers will require (and, BTW, that could raise our cleaning fees, too).
I've seen numerous hosts questioning these changes, and I genuinely wonder whether Airbnb's leadership has considered their implications for responsible operators. Or, given your increasing interest in hotels, perhaps independent hosts are simply becoming less important to your business strategy.
If the intent is to push hosts off the platform, CONGRATS... this should do the trick if you go through with these changes. But why would you want to push out the GOOD hosts rather than the bad? One would think you'd want to clean house by kicking out the bad hosts first.
I just find that weird.
And here is the most important thing to think about:
Airbnb has always had a PR problem with the "chores." EVERYONE gets that... especially good hosts, which is why we don't require them.
BUT...
Are you prepared for the PR fallout when there are more and more stories of guests burning down houses, people drowning, neighbors complaining about loud guests and pressuring cities to make STRs illegal, or Airbnb properties being used for human trafficking?
IF HOSTS CANNOT REQUIRE GUESTS TO SIGN A LEGALLY BINDING RENTAL AGREEMENT THAT SIMPLY LAYS OUT REASONABLE RULES TO KEEP THEM SAFE, OUR NEIGHBORS HAPPY, OUR CITIES' STR-FRIENDLY REGULATIONS IN PLACE, AND OUR PROPERTIES IN GREAT CONDITION, YOUR PR PROBLEM WILL BE MUCH, MUCH WORSE THAN YOUR "CHECKOUT INSTRUCTIONS" PROBLEM.
Nobody is asking Airbnb to defend bad hosts or unreasonable guest demands. We're asking you to distinguish between bad actors and responsible property owners who invest enormous resources into providing excellent guest experiences.
Airbnb doesn't own the homes that make its business possible. We do.
If Airbnb expects us to bear the responsibility, it must also respect our right to exercise reasonable authority.
You cannot demand accountability while systematically removing control.
I hope you will reconsider your actions and understand the benefits of keeping good hosts on the platform.
Sincerely,
Julie Hill
Property Owner & Short-Term Rental Host